Header Illustration

The Most Expensive Trout to Catch?

Matuka fly image

"Is that your first trout?"
"Yes it is," I replied, flushed with success.
"Well, it is the most expensive fish you will ever catch."
My excitement at catching the fish disappeared at once.
What had I done wrong?

The Avon River, is not high on fishermen's lists of famous trout water. In fact, the piece of the river that flowed alongside Hagley Park, smack in the middle of Christchurch, New Zealand, alongside a busy inner-city road, rated very low indeed. I had never seen anyone fishing there.

Avon River - Christchurch NZ

However close and lengthy examination of the water, on the way to and from Christchurch Boys High School, had revealed fish.

The River at this point was about a meter deep, from bank to bank. Long strands of weed waved in an irregular dance, in time with the currents. The bottom comprised of stones and rock, poking through the solid mud base.

The trout were hard to spot.

For starters there were few fish. Secondly, they held close alongside, or under the sheltering weed. Lastly, they were Brown trout, notoriously difficult to spot at any time.

With some help, I learned the lesson that it is better to look for movement, rather than the fish. Most often a moving shadow was the first sign. The white flash of an opening, and shutting mouth, became another dead giveaway.

(Article continues below advertisement)

The fact that the river held fish, visible fish, and was an easy bike ride from home, proved too much of a temptation. I had recently been given a light spinning set-up. A few Zeltic spinners, from Crombe & Merrit in the City, plus some advice on how to catch trout, saw me down by the river one Saturday morning.

My first casts, taught me more lessons. Casting directly to the fish was a definite no, no. Also the line could not pass over the fish before the lure. Any flash from the lure, or line, in the air would send the fish into a mad panic.

The lure had to pass the fish within a foot or so, and within a few centimetres of its depth. Too far away and the lure was studiously ignored. On the few times I managed to get the lure close to the fish, one of two things happened. The fish would swing across to look at the lure, and usually swing straight back to its lie, or it would take one look at the lure and streak off to the middle distance.

(Article continues below advertisement)

Chasing trout proved to be a frustrating exercise.

My previous experience had focused on Kahawai, and Salmon, near the river mouth and in the surf. Casting and retrieving to likely water was all that was required. It was rare to see the fish being cast to.

On the rare occasions I had cast to surface schools of Kahawai, they had been so intent on feeding, the splashdown of the lure in the middle of the school was treated with complete indifference.

I returned home troutless for the following many Saturdays, but each new expedition added to my store of information. I began to identify the lies where trout were likely to be holding. This meant that I wasted far less time looking for fish in fishless places. I learned to cast well ahead of the fish, and by careful line control, waft the lure as close to the fish as possible.

Finally, the inevitable happened, I hooked up.

The fight was short, and the fish was soon lifted out of the water, still dangling from the rod tip, and on to the bank. (Not all lessons are learned at once.) I was totally rapt. Here was a sport that combined hunting and fishing. The chase was as important as the catch.

Many years later a customer in my shop described this in the best way I have heard. He said that the difference between saltwater fishing and trout fishing, is that in trout fishing the foreplay is more important than the climax, and in saltwater the exact opposite is true.

My sense of self pride at catching this beautiful fish was immense. It was then that I heard the words that opened this story.

"What have I done wrong, Sir?" I asked, (the "sir" seemed a very good idea under the circumstances at the time), "I have got a license."

"Oh, its not that Sonny," he laughed, "It's just that you think it is the fish that has been hooked. You have got it the wrong way round. You are now hooked for life. It is the most expensive fish you will ever catch."

I was hooked, and I would not hazard a guess on how much money I have spent on chasing more fish.

When I arrived home that afternoon, my parents reckoned that I was still quivering and so was the fish.

Mum prepared the fish that night, a French recipe with almonds as a prominent feature. The result was, in a word, well two words, absolutely disgusting. The trout tasted like mud. I became an avid trout catch and release man long before it became fashionable, and necessary.

A Postscript:

It was some time later that I learned that I had in fact been fishing in a banned area. The Ranger who gave me this information, luckily, thought that youth should be encouraged, rather than damned, and directed me to legal, and more fish-holding, water.

Buzzer fly

Article written by Tony Bishop (Bish)

book image link to free book

My first trout fishing book Fishing Smarter for Trout is now up on this site and free to read. Includes regular updates and new stuff.

Read More

Featured article header graphic

Why Doesn't Anyone Bow to a Trout Anymore?


I recently noticed I was losing more hooked fish by way of broken leaders or hooks pulled out. Why? I checked the leader material I used and found no problem. Still tough as old boots and broke just over the line weight. No answers there.

Read More

Featured article header graphic

How to Release Fish with the Best Chance of Survival

Ban Treble Hooks

Don't be fooled, just unhooking a fish and throwing it back in the water is not going to ensure a fish will survive the catch and release.

Releasing fish correctly has become a very important factor in preserving fish stocks for the future, but it needs to be done correctly.

This article sets out 5 "release rules" that provide the maximum survivability for the fish. There is also a couple of extra 'rules' and links to more information.

Read it here.

Bishfish Facebook site Blog email Bish

Maori Greenstone (NZ Jade) Hook Ornament