Header Illustration

Fishing Cheats: the lengths they go to, to win or claim a record

Exposing the dark side of the fishing force.

A lot of years ago I was out on a charter boat from Kona, in Hawaii.

Before leaving the dock I had a 'frank and meaningful exchange of views' with the skipper about the habit in that part of the world, back then, of the deck-hand, on a strike, lifting the rod out of the rod-holder and passing it to the angler. Sometimes even setting the hook on the way.

I made it very clear this must not happen. The skipper grudgingly agreed.

bull mahi mahi

Anyway, not too far into the trip a thumping great Mahi-Mahi jumped on one of the rods, and the deck-hand grabbed the rod out of the holder and handed it to me. I gave him an earful, while setting about landing the fish.

Once on board it turned out to be a very big fish indeed - so big that the skipper wanted to weigh it in as a possible record.

I pointed out that we could not do that because the deck-hand had handed me the rod in contravention of IGFA rules. The skipper suggested I might like to forget that, especially as it would be me who would have the record. I said I would not do so.

The rest of the trip was conducted in what might be described as a less than convivial atmosphere.

The atmosphere changed from cool to downright frigid when back at the dock other skippers and deck-hands asked when we were going to weigh the fish. These questions stopped stone-dead when I announced that the deckhand had handed me the rod, although one or two suggested I should not let that get in the way.

(Article continues below advertisement)

This episode, which I stress was about 40 years ago,was recalled a little while ago when I was having a few drinks with a group of fishy characters. The group included well-known big-game fishing charter-boat skippers, some deck-hands, and small-boat charter skippers, and a few fly-fishing guides.

The subject of discussions was records and competitions, and the lengths some people will go to to win them. These discussions exposed the dark side of the fishing force.

Without exception, each of the group, (around 15), had been, and are still, regularly offered financial inducements to 'bend the rules' so that the client would win a competition or gain a world record. Actually they are offered bribes, not financial inducements, let's call it for what it is - a payment to cheat.

What were they offered bribes for?

Potential records seem to attract a lot of cheats; people with enough money to buy what money should not be able to buy. Some people it seems will pay an awful lot of money to have a fish mount over the fire-place with a World Record Certificate under it.

For them it does not matter a fat rat's ass how it happens, just that it happens.

Amongst skippers there are a few cheats too; those that will bend the rules, like the Kona skipper at the beginning of this piece, to gain more results on their bragging board, and perhaps sponsorship money, free tackle, and more clients.

(Article continues below advertisement)

Here are just a few examples from the record chasing scene:

Once you get into the competition area, the hunger to win, backed by the lure of the prizes, prize money, fame and sponsorship, can bring out the cheats. We all have probably heard the litany of skullduggery that goes on during competitions:

Cheating does not just happen in salt water.

(Article continues below advertisement)

Many fly-fishing guides will know occasions when their client confronted by a really big trout, say they have not got the skills to catch it, and ask the guide to have a go.

If the guide lands the fish, the client is very keen to have a photo taken of him holding the fish. (Just a quick note, it is really not a good idea for the cheating client to stick the photo up on the internet, or use it in a a magazine article, captioned as his 'kill'.)

Some cheats buy trophy fish from another angler that actually caught the fish. The mount may look great on the wall, but I wonder how many times the cheat tells the story of catching it before conscience finally pricks too hard.

Using bait in fly-fishing competitions still attracts a few cheats, as it does for those seeking big fish for the wall, regardless of the ethics of the trout's capture.

So how do we stamp out cheating?

Give up on trying to stamp it out completely, but continue with efforts to catch as many cheats as possible. Cheats, rogues and rascals have been around too long, and sadly may always be around.

We are faced with continually refining and strengthening our detection methods.

As prize-money goes up competition organisers have been forced to introduce stronger controls, like the use of observers on all boats, on the water and airborne observation, and the like.

But these methods are unlikely to stop all cheating, so is there one thing that might?

The answer is of course no. But we can think on this; in any cheating activity, where any more than one person is involved in that activity, it is a conspiracy. Any conspiracy is only as strong as its weakest link. Any more than two people involved and the strength of the conspiracy weakens exponentially as more people are added.

There are no end to stories of revealed cheats by disgruntled crew members, unseen observers, fights over prize money, and outbreaks of remorse and honesty, often fuelled by booze, by one or some of the conspirators.

I prefer to believe that the vast majority of fishermen do not cheat. But the cheats might lend an ear to that old but very true adage: "It is a bloody big wheel that does not turn full circle."

As for the rest of us - as William Sherwood Fox said: "Of all the liars among mankind, the fisherman is the most trustworthy"

fish graphic

Article written by Tony Bishop (Bish)

Featured article header graphic

How to Release Fish with the Best Chance of Survival

Ban Treble Hooks

Don't be fooled, just unhooking a fish and throwing it back in the water is not going to ensure a fish will survive the catch and release.

Releasing fish correctly has become a very important factor in preserving fish stocks for the future, but it needs to be done correctly.

This article sets out 5 "release rules" that provide the maximum survivability for the fish. There is also a couple of extra 'rules' and links to more information.

Read it here.

Related article section header

Maori Greenstone hook ornament

What you need to know about fishing hooks

Why so many hook types, sizes, and shapes?

You wander into the tackle shop to buy some hooks, and there in front of you is a huge array of sizes and variations. Confused? Don't be, help is at hand.

Read more here

Related article section header

How to tie fishing knots properly & securely

fishing knot

It is my guess that more fish are lost to poorly tied knots, than from any other single factor.

There are many knots available to fishers, but no matter which knot you choose there is one factor that remains true. If you do not practice tying the chosen knot so that you can tie it easily and securely, you will lose fish to knots coming undone...

Read more here

Bishfish Facebook site Blog email Bish

Maori Greenstone (NZ Jade) Hook Ornament